Payments explained

Stripe vs PayPal vs Square: How to Choose for a Small Business

By the Chargedeck team 7 min read

The short answer

Choose Stripe if you sell mostly online and want the widest choice of payment methods and connected tools. Choose PayPal if your buyers already have PayPal accounts and look for its button. Choose Square if you also sell in person and want the card reader and your online sales in one account.

All three are payment processors that pay into your bank account, so the right one depends on your situation more than on a headline rate. Below are a decision table by situation, a checklist for comparing real costs on each pricing page, and a way to avoid betting everything on one.

What each one is best known for

Stripe

Stripe is online-first. It is known for being developer-friendly, for supporting many payment methods, and for the long list of website builders, plugins and apps that connect to it. It tends to suit sellers whose business lives on the web: digital products, services, small online shops, anything stitched together from several tools.

PayPal

PayPal's strength is on the buyer's side. Many shoppers already have an account, recognize the button and can pay without typing a card number. It tends to suit sellers whose customers ask "do you take PayPal?", and anyone selling to people who are cautious about entering card details on a site they have only just found.

Square

Square is known for in-person selling: card readers and a point of sale, with online payments in the same account. It tends to suit market traders, cafes, salons and makers who take cards face to face and want web orders to show up in the same reports and payouts.

None of these is a fixed lane. Each has added tools that overlap with the other two, which is why the choice is easier to make from your situation than from a feature list.

Decision table: pick by situation

Your situationLikely fitWhy
You sell only online: digital products, services, a small web shopStripeOnline-first, many payment methods, and most online tools connect to it
Your buyers ask whether you take PayPalPayPalThey already have an account and trust the button
You sell at markets, in a shop or at events, and want online orders tooSquareReader and online sales share one account, with one set of reports and payouts
You plan to connect apps, plugins or custom codeStripeDeveloper-friendly and widely supported; still check your specific tool's list
You already use one of the three and it worksKeep itA new account means new verification, new payouts and new reports to learn
You sell to buyers in several countriesCompare all three for your countryCross-border and currency conversion charges differ; use the checklist below
You are brand new with no sales historyThe one you can fully verify todayAny processor may review a new account, so complete the identity and bank checks early

Start from the row that describes most of your sales, not the exception. If two rows apply equally, go with the one your buyers care about. They notice the payment options on the page. They never see your dashboard.

How to compare the real cost

This guide does not rank the three by fee, because the answer changes with your country, your typical order size and how your buyers pay. Open each provider's pricing page for your country and write down the same seven things.

What to checkWhy it matters
Online card fee: the percentage and the fixed amount per chargeThe fixed amount weighs most on small orders
In-person fee, if you will use a readerIt is often a different rate from the online one
Fee for cards issued in another countryAn extra charge on international buyers
Currency conversionApplies when the buyer pays in one currency and you are paid out in another
Dispute or chargeback feeCharged when a buyer contests a payment with their bank
Payout speed, and any fee for faster payoutsDecides how long your money is in transit
Holds, reserves and account review termsTells you when a payout can be paused

As of November 2026, Stripe's standard US online card rate is 2.9% + 30 cents per successful charge, listed on Stripe's pricing page. PayPal publishes its merchant fees by country on paypal.com, and Square lists its rates on Square's pricing page. Their numbers are left out here on purpose: they vary by country and payment type, and a copied figure goes stale.

Worked example: why the fixed part matters

Take Stripe's US rate and two shops that each sell $2,000 a month. This is arithmetic, not a forecast.

  • 100 orders of $20. Each charge costs $0.58 + $0.30 = $0.88, which is 4.4% of the order. The month costs $88.
  • 10 orders of $200. Each charge costs $5.80 + $0.30 = $6.10, which is 3.05% of the order. The month costs $61.

Same sales, a $27 difference, all of it from the fixed 30 cents. So when you compare processors, run this sum with each one's numbers at your own typical order size: fee per order = price times the percentage, plus the fixed amount.

Four things that matter more than a fraction of a percent

  • What your buyers expect to see. A payment option they trust is worth more than a slightly lower rate they never notice.
  • Whether your tools connect. Check that your website builder, booking tool or checkout builder supports the processor before you open the account.
  • Account reviews and holds. All three can pause a payout or ask for documents under their own terms, for example on a new account or after a sudden jump in sales. Complete verification on day one. Who holds your money on a payment platform explains how holds work.
  • Where disputes are handled. You answer chargebacks in the processor's dashboard, so choose one whose dashboard and support you can live with.

When none of the three is the right model

Stripe, PayPal and Square are processors. They move the money and you remain the seller, which means the tax, refund and dispute responsibilities stay with you. If you sell software or digital goods to buyers in many countries and would rather not handle tax registration yourself, a merchant of record platform is a different model worth a look. Merchant of record vs payment processor explains the trade and what it costs.

If what you need is recurring billing with card fields on your own site, use the processor's own billing tools or its official plugin for your platform.

You do not have to bet on one

Nothing stops you holding more than one account: Square for the stall, say, and PayPal or Stripe for online orders. Opening an account does not lock you in. What locks you in is having to rebuild every product page, link and button each time you change your mind.

That is the part Chargedeck removes. It is a checkout page builder that sits in front of whichever of the three you already have. You build a branded checkout page once and share it as a link, a QR code or a button on your site, and the buyer's payment goes straight into your own processor account. The processor is an account setting, so you can switch to another one later without rebuilding a page, and your links stay the same.

There is a guide for each: a branded alternative to Stripe's own checkout, a checkout page builder for PayPal and a checkout page builder for Square. Pages can be priced in USD, GBP, EUR, CAD or AUD.

Whichever processor you connect, the price is the same: a flat monthly fee from $9.99, with 0% of your sales taken (see pricing). Your processor's own fees still apply to each payment, and refunds and chargebacks are handled in your processor dashboard, not in Chargedeck. Two limits to know before you choose: Chargedeck pages do not show Apple Pay or Google Pay buttons, and Chargedeck does not do subscriptions.

FAQ

Common questions

Is PayPal or Stripe better for a small business?

Stripe tends to suit online-first sellers who want many payment methods and connected tools. PayPal tends to suit sellers whose buyers already have PayPal accounts and ask for it. If both describe you, start with the one your buyers mention most.

Which is cheapest: Stripe, PayPal or Square?

It depends on your country, your typical order size and whether you sell online or in person. Take each provider's percentage and fixed fee from its pricing page and run them against your own average order.

Can I use more than one payment processor?

Yes. They are separate accounts with separate payouts and reports, so the cost is a little more bookkeeping. One common split is one processor for in-person sales and another for online.

Do I need a website to take payments with Stripe, PayPal or Square?

No. Each offers its own basic payment link, and a checkout page builder gives you a hosted page with more on it. See how to create a payment link for the steps.

Can I switch processor later?

Yes, though your payment history and past payouts stay in the old account. If your checkout pages are built in a tool that works with all three, such as Chargedeck, the pages and links do not change when you switch.

Keep reading

Related guides

Build once, use any of the three

Connect the Stripe, PayPal or Square account you already have and build a checkout page you will not have to rebuild if you switch. Free for 7 days, no card.

See pricing