A percentage fee costs little when you sell little and grows with every dollar you earn. A flat fee is a fixed cost that stays put. At $500 a month in sales the two can cost almost the same. At $5,000 a month, a 10% cut is $500, while a $9.99 flat fee plus a typical 2.9% card fee is $154.99.
This post puts five pricing models in one table at four sales levels, gives you the break-even formula to run on your own numbers, and says plainly what the percentage tools include that a flat-fee tool does not.
Two ways a selling tool gets paid
A percentage cut, often called a transaction fee, means the tool keeps a share of each sale. No sales, no fee. A flat fee is a monthly price that is the same whether you sell $50 or $50,000. Some tools combine the two.
Before you compare any two tools, ask three questions of each fee:
- Does the percentage include card processing? Some do. With others you pay your card processor separately, on top.
- Is there a fixed amount per sale as well? A per-sale fee of 30 or 50 cents matters a lot on a $5 product and hardly at all on a $200 one.
- Does the plan have a sales cap? Some flat plans move you to a higher price once your sales pass a threshold. Sellfy, for example, charges no transaction fee but caps each plan by yearly sales: $29 a month up to $10,000 a year, $79 up to $50,000 and $159 up to $200,000, as of November 2026. $10,000 a year is about $833 a month.
What each model costs from $500 to $20,000 a month
These are the published fees as of November 2026:
- Gumroad: 10% + 50 cents per direct sale, no monthly fee. Card processing is included. Sales through its Discover marketplace are charged 30%.
- Lemon Squeezy: 5% + 50 cents per sale, no monthly fee. Card processing is included.
- Payhip Free: 5% per sale, no monthly fee. Card processing is separate.
- Podia Mover: $49 a month plus 5% of sales. Card processing is separate.
- Chargedeck Starter: $9.99 a month and 0% of your sales. Card processing is separate and paid to your own processor. As a typical card fee, Stripe's standard US online card rate is 2.9% + 30 cents per successful charge.
The table shows the monthly cost at four levels of monthly sales, listed across the top. Chargedeck appears twice so that like is compared with like: once with a typical 2.9% card fee added, to set against the tools whose percentage already covers card processing, and once alone, to set against the tools where the card fee is extra on both sides.
| Tool and fee | Card processing included? | $500 | $2,000 | $5,000 | $20,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gumroad, 10% | Yes | $50 | $200 | $500 | $2,000 |
| Lemon Squeezy, 5% | Yes | $25 | $100 | $250 | $1,000 |
| Chargedeck Starter, $9.99 plus a 2.9% card fee | Yes, added here | $24.49 | $67.99 | $154.99 | $589.99 |
| Payhip Free, 5% | No | $25 | $100 | $250 | $1,000 |
| Podia Mover, $49 plus 5% | No | $74 | $149 | $299 | $1,049 |
| Chargedeck Starter, $9.99 alone | No | $9.99 | $9.99 | $9.99 | $9.99 |
Compare the three "Yes" rows with each other and the three "No" rows with each other. All figures are arithmetic on the published rates, not a forecast. The table leaves out the fixed per-sale amounts (50 cents at Gumroad and Lemon Squeezy, 30 cents at Stripe) because they depend on how many orders make up your sales.
Adding the per-sale fees back in
Suppose your $2,000 comes from 80 orders of $25. Gumroad is $200 plus 80 times $0.50, which is $240. Lemon Squeezy is $100 plus $40, which is $140. Chargedeck Starter on Stripe is $9.99 plus $58 plus 80 times $0.30, which is $91.99.
The fixed part bites hardest on low prices. On a $10 item, Gumroad's 10% + 50 cents is $1.50, or 15% of the price. Lemon Squeezy's 5% + 50 cents is $1.00, or 10%. Stripe's 2.9% + 30 cents is 59 cents, or 5.9%.
The break-even formula
The break-even point is the monthly sales figure at which a flat fee and a percentage cost the same. Below it the percentage tool is cheaper. Above it the flat fee is.
Break-even monthly sales = the flat monthly fee divided by the percentage you would stop paying.
If the percentage tool's cut includes card processing, first subtract the card rate you will pay yourself, because that cost does not go away. Here it is worked through for Chargedeck Starter at $9.99, using the fees above as of November 2026:
- Against Gumroad's 10%: $9.99 divided by (0.10 minus 0.029) is $9.99 divided by 0.071, about $141 a month.
- Against Lemon Squeezy's 5%: $9.99 divided by (0.05 minus 0.029) is $9.99 divided by 0.021, about $476 a month.
- Against Payhip Free's 5%: card processing is separate on both sides, so it is $9.99 divided by 0.05, about $200 a month.
- Against Podia Mover: there is no break-even on price, because $49 a month is already more than $9.99 before the 5%. Podia is a broader product than a checkout page, so check its site for what the plan includes before you compare on price alone.
The same formula works between two plans of one tool: divide the difference in monthly price by the difference in percentage. As of November 2026, Payhip's $29 a month plan takes 2% instead of 5%, so it pays for itself above $29 divided by 0.03, about $967 a month in sales. Its $99 a month plan takes 0%, which beats the $29 plan above $70 divided by 0.02, or $3,500 a month. Podia's $99 a month Shaker plan has no sales fee, so it beats Mover above $50 divided by 0.05, or $1,000 a month.
What the percentage buys
A higher fee is not automatically a worse deal. The percentage tools include things a flat-fee checkout tool does not:
- Merchant of record service. Gumroad and Lemon Squeezy are the legal seller of your product and handle sales tax on each sale. Chargedeck does not do this: you are the seller. Merchant of record vs payment processor explains what that service is worth.
- Marketplace traffic. Gumroad's Discover marketplace can put your product in front of buyers who were not looking for you. It takes 30% of those sales (as of November 2026), and nothing if it brings none. Selling digital products without a marketplace covers the other side of that trade.
- Nothing to pay in a quiet month. With no monthly fee, a month with no sales costs nothing.
- One fee instead of two. When card processing is bundled, there is a single number to think about.
A decision rule for your own numbers
- Take last month's sales and order count. If you are just starting, use an honest guess, not a hope.
- Work out each option's cost: sales times the percentage, plus orders times the per-sale fee, plus any monthly fee.
- If you are below the break-even point, or you need a merchant of record or a marketplace, stay on the percentage tool. It is the better choice for you right now.
- If you are above it and comfortable being the seller, move to the flat fee.
- Look at the gap over a year, not a month. At $2,000 a month, Gumroad's 10% (as of November 2026) comes to $2,400 a year, and Chargedeck Starter plus a 2.9% card fee comes to $815.88. The difference is $1,584.12. The real question is whether tax handling and marketplace reach are worth that much to you.
- Run the sum again whenever your sales double.
Where Chargedeck fits
Chargedeck is the flat-fee side of this comparison. It is a checkout page builder that connects to your own Stripe, PayPal or Square account. Payments go straight into that account, Chargedeck takes 0% of your sales, and no plan has a sales cap. Starter is $9.99 a month, Growth $24.99 and Unlimited $49.99, and what changes between them is the number of brands and storefronts (Growth also adds advanced analytics), as the pricing page shows. Your processor's card fees still apply, which is why the table adds them.
What it leaves out: Chargedeck is not a merchant of record, it does not calculate sales tax or VAT, and it is not a marketplace that brings buyers. You bring the audience and you handle your own tax.
For tool-by-tool tables with dated sources, start at the comparison hub or go straight to Chargedeck compared with Gumroad. To see why a tool that never holds your money tends to charge a flat fee, read who holds your money on a payment platform.
